The Future of Electronic Paper Monday, October 15, 2007 - Iddo Genuth Home >> Articles >> The Future of X |
Thirty-five years in the making, electronic paper is now closer than ever to changing the way we read, write, and study — a revolution so profound that some see it as second only to the invention of the printing press in the 15th century. Made of flexible material, requiring ultra-low power consumption, cheap to manufacture, and—most important—easy and convenient to read, e-papers of the future are just around the corner, with the promise to hold libraries on a chip and replace most printed newspapers before the end of the next decade. This article will cover the history, technology, and future of what will be the second paper revolution. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Nearly 35 years later, TFOT sat down with Nick Sheridon to ask him about his historic invention. Q: How did it all start?
I stopped the Gyricon work and eventually invented a new electronic-printing technology based on ionography. This became a large program at Xerox, consuming perhaps $150 million; this number is hard to establish. We developed and were in early-manufacturing operations of the world's first multifunction desktop machine—printer, copier, input scanner, and fax—when this program was cancelled. This left me free to invent the concept of electronic paper. Much has been written about the incredible myopia of Xerox executives of the time, so I won't go into that except to say that there were numerous other opportunities to enormously expand Xerox's business that were similarly fumbled. Xerox had enough money to create an incredible research lab with top-notch people, but Xerox management could not shake off the copier mentality. Q: So how was e-paper born?
Q: Was there a eureka moment, or was the outcome more or less anticipated from the start? A: There was a eureka moment when the need for e-paper crystallized in my mind and I realized—or thought I did—the magnitude of the challenge. Very euphoric! Q: It's been almost 35 years since the invention of e-paper. Why do you think it is taking so long to enter the market? A: E-paper has entered the market, but not yet in a big way. Gyricon sold message signs, and E Ink Corporation provided the e-paper for the Sony Reader sold in Japan. Kent Displays is also selling signs. No technology is yet sufficiently paper-like to grab the huge latent market widely recognized to be there. More invention is needed. This is a lot like the early days of television development, when everyone knew what was needed but getting the technology right was tough. Q: What do you see as the obstacles facing mass adoption of e-paper technology? A: No technology is sufficiently paper-like, yet. By this, I mean a display medium that is thin, flexible, capable of storing readable images without power consumption, highly readable in ambient light, and has good resolution, high whiteness, and good contrast — and is pretty cheap. A big part of this equation is the addressing electronics. Organic thin film transistors, or TFTs, will provide flexible addressing at a low cost, and other technologies show promise, but none of these are quite ready. Q: Are these problems currently being addressed by the industry? A: More than a dozen companies have announced work on active e-paper programs, and there are a number of start-ups. As I mentioned, the low cost and flexible electronic-addressing capability of organic TFT technology is important and is being intensively developed by a number of organizations. Still, I have not yet seen the ideal e-paper media solution. Q: Are you still working on the development of e-paper? A: Xerox closed its Gyricon operation in December 2005 for financial reasons. (I was director of research. I am now working independently and doing some consulting. And, yes, I am working to invent the perfect e-paper medium. Q: When do you think we will see widespread use of e-paper? A: I think the revolution will evolve, first as handheld displays of high contrast that are readable in direct sunlight —probably in the next year or two—followed by low power-consuming book readers (available in Japan, and more widely as intellectual-property rights issues are sorted out); and over the next five years, electronic signs and billboards. The pocket document reader will take a little longer. Q: How do you see the future of e-paper?
How e-Paper Works
Over the years, a number of methods for creating e-ink have been developed. The Gyricon e-ink developed in the 70s by Nick Sheridon at Xerox is based on a thin sheet of flexible plastic containing a layer of tiny plastic beads, each encapsulated in a little pocket of oil and thus able to freely rotate within the plastic sheet. Each hemisphere of a bead has a different color and a different electrical charge. When an electric field is applied by the backplane, the beads rotate, creating a two-colored pattern. This method of creating e-ink was dubbed bichromal frontplane. Originally, bichromal frontplane had a number of limitations, including relatively low brightness and resolution and a lack of color. Although these issues are still being tackled, other forms of e-ink, with improved properties compared to the original Gyricon, have been developed over the years. One such technology is electrophoretic frontplane, developed by the E Ink Corporation. Electrophoretic frontplane consists of millions of tiny microcapsules, each approximately 100 microns in diameter—about as wide as a human hair. Each microcapsule is filled with a clear fluid containing positively charged white particles and negatively charged black particles. When a negative electric field is applied, the white particles move to the top of the microcapsule, causing the area to appear to the viewer as a white dot, while the black particles move to the bottom of the capsule and are thus hidden from view. When a positive electric field is applied, the black particles migrate to the top and the white particles move to the bottom, generating black text or a picture.
The brightness and resolution of electrophoretic-based e-ink is better than that of bichromal-based e-ink, but both are monochromatic in nature. To create color, E Ink joined hands with the Japanese company Toppan Printing, which produces color filters. Another drawback of electrophoretic e-ink is its low refresh rate, making electrophoretic e-ink unsuitable for displaying animation or video. Since it takes time for the particles to move from one side of the microcapsule to the other, drawing a new text or image is too slow and creates a flicker effect.
Although other potential technologies for developing advanced color electronic paper exist such as photonic crystals (P-ink) recently covered by TFOT, many analysts believe that ChLCD technology could become the dominant e-paper technology of the next decade. This assessment relates to the high level of maturity exemplified by the current LCD industry, as well as to the fact that ChLCD technology currently offers what many analysts see as the ideal list of features for e-paper: flexibility and even bendability; thinness, at approximately 0.8 millimeters; lightness; a bi-stable nature, requiring no power to maintain an image and very little power to change it; good brightness, contrast, and resolution; as well as vivid color and a decent refresh rate capable of displaying animation and possibly even video.
TFOT asked Till Moor from Siemens to describe Siemens's interest in e-paper technology.
Having mentioned in this article a number of potential applications for e-paper, it is possible that the most important applications of this technology have not yet been invented. In the same way that Theodore H. Maiman did not foresee the DVD player when he invented the first laser in 1960, so might we still be in the dark as to the true potential of e-paper technologies. The Future of E-paperTFOT interviewed Nick Hampshire, an analyst at AFAICS Research, which focuses on publishing and media-related technology. Nick has been following the e-paper industry for many years, and his insights can shed light on both the current and future state of the industry. Q: Why do you think it took almost 30 years for e-paper to enter the market?
Q: What are the current obstacles facing mass adoption of e-paper technology? A: The main obstacle is price. Our research shows that the cost of an e-paper-based reader has to fall to under $100 before a significant percentage of the population will buy one. Even then, they will only buy if suitable content is available at a reasonable cost. The second obstacle is availability of content. Q: How do you see the future of e-paper? A: The technology of printed electronics will deliver low-cost production; we could be looking at give away e-paper display products by 2015. Content availability is a question of making sure that publishers are aware of the potential offered by e-paper displays, and prepared to make the investment to provide that content. Q: What do you think will be the "killer application" of e-paper? Q: When do you predict we will see the real e-paper revolution? A: It has already started but will become a real mass market in about 2012. Further discussion of electronic paper see this thread on the TFOT forums. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Other News | Brain Surgery Helps a Mute Man Speak | 'Quantum Computer' a Stage Closer |
Other Pictures | Flame – Revolutionary Walking Robot | Cell Phone Usage Damages Memory |
|
|
|||
|
|||
Multi-Touch E-Paper so you can not only read but write as well. | |||
|
|||
While at IBM Research I worked to create a technology called rewriteable paper. It used bacteriorhodopsin, a material derived from pond scum. The Rhodopsin molecule is used by the eye. This material can be coated onto thin plastic sheeting. It can be written by a printer but it can also be erased by the printer and rewritten. The plastic sheet has the properties of paper, has no electronics, and can be reused millions of times. It can be manufactured in bulk and be made for pennies a sheet. IBM dropped the project. |
|||
|
|||
Making a so called "Multi-Touch E-Paper" will increase the manufacturing cost of the paper (additional components) and will probably increase the power consumption. |
|||
|
|||
Where is the profit on creating a paper that is rewritable? People in the paper business might see rewritable paper as a threat. It's a shame IBM dropped the project. I don't know how much of their business is in paper, but they could make out really well on the printer side. Transfer all the costs to the printer away from the paper? Patent the technology and take on HP? |
|||
|
|||
We keep inventing things that can't be recycled, will end up creating poison in landfills, and have no part of the production be the requirement of how to dispose of it safely. Great idea for the people selling the newest toys to the instant gratification crowd. Lousy for the environment. It won't save trees...it will just add pollution to the earth. |
|||
|
|||
It seems to me, and I may be wrong, that there isn\\\'t any need for another device to put in my pocket just to read \\\'paper\\\' documents. Why isn\\\'t there any mention in this article about the merging of cellphones/PDAs/Laptop Computers. It seems that creating \\\'paper\\\' documents will be directly linked to the current progression of the multifunction Cell phone. Seemingly why so many companies dropped their production of e-paper - It simply doesn\\\'t achieve what can already be done digitally. |
|||
|
|||
A product whose time has come. I think that portablility plus the readability of text on paper instead of a screen will indeed make a difference. Downloading to the e paper is another critical factor and the increased use of wireless networks may be the deciding factor in the takeup of this technology. Think of having all your school textbooks available, but only the weight of a sheet of paper. |
|||
|
|||
hay Dianne the same recycle thought came 2 me too but if u think abt it in the long run its goan to save paper & that translates in trees saved..more over 2day new technology has to to be recyclable 2 survive. & Monty_121 what seems 2 me is this product aims to be very cheap & u mite end up using as paper clips what i mean is its gone to replace paper & hence no new extra baggage is introduced in fact since e-paper has memory it can replace multiple sheet of paper in a single page...imagine u have a single sheet of paper that while traveling can carry ur entire novel collection & (i hope u can download new ones or the newspaper wirelessly.. which in turn saves a lot of paper= gud 4 earth... i believe this could be start of a revolution eagerly awaiting its arrival |
|||
|
|||
I don't see any problems with this technology; however, this will certainly have a significant impact on the printing companies. Not only that, if we're able to download books onto the e-paper, wouldn't that mean that there must be some system to prevent massive free downloads? I don't want to starve myself writing a book that i don't get anything out of it. |
|||
|
|||
It would be fantastic if books would be published in electronic form. You can apply the flexibility of a computer to the text (e.g. search it), and while away from the computer you could just read it like you would a regular book. However, this is where copyright issues come into this. The authors of books would probably want to enforce the copyright in order to protect their sales. They wouldn't like their e-book to be shared over peer-to-peer networks/similar. So... I think that digital rights management(DRM) , while many people think is unfair and restrictive, will be a widespread reality in so-called "e-books". Either that, or a major rethink of the rights of authors and readers and of copyright law will occur! If DRM will be applied to e-books, I only hope there will be an open implementation of it, so it can be used on free/open-source operating systems, e.g. GNU/Linux. Hence, readers would not have to put up with expensive and potentially inflexible e-book-reading software. |
|||
|
|||
why do we want to change paper |
|||
|
|||
I Never knew this much. I never knew about electronic paper!!! | |||
|
|||
e-Paper will rock. I did my final year major project on it during uni studying Industrial Design. The biggest factor that has slowed its devlopment is price, and with more companies working on the tech that will soon be less of an issue as more competition enters the market. It is such a promising technology I don't understand why people on this forum can't understand how revolutionary this will be. I do agree with an earlier comment, that we need to think about the design for disassembly issues surrounding this tech and what it will mean environmentally. I suggest that with the current green trend, companies will set up plants that dispose of the old versions of readers at the end of their lifecycles, similar to what european car companies have been doing for some time now. Can't wait til this is finally released widespread with proper online infrastructure to back it up. Imagine having a subscription to your newspaper download through your wireless connection at home every morniing |
|||
|
|||
"creating paper documents will be directly linked to the current progression of the multifunction Cell phone." Check out the Motorola F3 phone. :) "It simply doesn't achieve what can already be done digitally." The problem with LCD displays is that they use power all the time, and they're less pleasant to look at (to most people, anyway). |
|||
|
|||
yeah, paper is rollable and bendable,even foldable, but hardcover books are not, leading me to wonder, why all the developers and marketers seem fixated on the bendable aspect of epaper. not like its going to matter if we can fold it right away. lots of us would be thrilled to replace a whole library of books for just one device even if it weren't bendable. I don-t need it to be a single sheet of paper, what I am far more interested in is a big, washable, nonglossy page I can read in the sunlight. And if it is color and can change fast, then bye bye monitor screens, even if its an inch thick. |
|||
|
|||
There are televisions that are 0,3cm thick so make them 0,5cm and we have multitouch monitors! E paper usage in daily life is expensive and better is to print something out! |
|||
|
|||
yeah, paper is rollable and bendable,even foldable, but hardcover books are not, leading me to wonder, why all the developers and marketers seem fixated on the bendable aspect of epaper. not like its going to matter if we can fold it right away. lots of us would be thrilled to replace a whole library of books for just one device even if it weren't bendable. I don-t need it to be a single sheet of paper, what I am far more interested in is a big, washable, nonglossy page I can read in the sunlight. Lingerie Wholesale And if it is color and can change fast, then bye bye monitor screens, even if its an inch thick. |
|||
|
|||
why more people do not read news papers | |||
|
|||
Does anybody know if I can already buy epaper somewhere ? I am talking about an epaper that present one or 2 images the whole time ??? i would be very thankful vor an answer |
|||
|
|||
What would be useful is an A4 times two or times four book for musicians. We could have all our music books in one place and be able to see two / four pages at a time. This would also be useful for schools, churches and local music groups. |
|||
|
|||
Talk about perspective. most of you are missing some of the potentials. Once it gets going it will conmtinue to drop in price, but this will save some inductries Millions of Dollars |
|||
|
|||
I've always agreed with Brian (8/20/08). Why the fascination with bendable displays? Like, I can't wait until somebody pushes a book into the edge of my little paper screen and then it gets a crease forever after that. Or how about having to keep bending this roll-up stuff back so the end isn't always curling up while you try to read it? And speaking of bending and creasing, these things will always be coated with a mildly to very specular protective surface. Trying to push down the bent parts to read where the glare is obfuscating the text is going to be totally maddening. Take the flexible thing, stick it between two hard plastic or glass plates, and I'm in. |
|||
|
|||
Hardcovers are just that...hard COVERS. Killer app will be video. A rollaway display will enable small form factor when carrying and larger viewable form factor when viewing |
|||
|
|||
If you go to the Baen website, you will find that some publishers have already started moving towards eBooks. If anything they have found that they sell even more books now, then they did before. |
|||
|
|||
Why e-paper? Are you kidding anyone whose had to move there personal library should be able to tell you why. Try moving to another country. I would love it if I could have all my art books in one small compact thing. I also would love not to have to carry a ton of books just to teach either. I am betting the flexible is for doctors and signs. How about not having to go through a ton of reference books. Thank you e-paper please hurry the hell up. |
|||
|
|||
Is it necessary to use a themperature sensor for E-Paper? how to mapping vs. themperature ? |
|||
|
|||
I'd love it if someone could please invent a laptop with an e-paper display. I don't mind if I couldn't see video on it, and if it was just greyscale. I don't enjoy staring at a computer screen, it's like looking into the light from a flashlight! Please develop an e-paper monitor for computers! |
|||
|
|||
I second Donna's point. Why is still no epaper monitor? Do you guys have any idea how painful it is to write a sixty page thesis on a backlit screen? I would pay exhorbitant amounts of money to buy something that doesn't kill my eyes! |
|||
|
|||
Tim, you are aware that your monitor's brightness can be adjusted, are you not? Re: e-paper, this stuff could save the news industry. I've worked for a newspaper for 30 years...we are going the way of the horse & carriage unless we get on board with this stuff NOW. It will be messy and painful because people will lose their jobs, but in the long run, the publishing industry as a whole will benefit. We can develop ways to deal with the environmental impact. Go for it!! |
|||
|
|||
I'm sure epaper on the underground would be a massive cost saver. All that free newspaper left on carriages has to currently be retrieved. E-paper may become a personal item that updates on a daily basis. |
|||
|
|||
Stop thinking in such a miniscule state of mind. Think what you could do. Huge Billboards that change data electronically and not by hand. A laptop with a HUGE computer screen that rolls up next to the battery, or folds, and uses a much lower percentage of your battery power. A computer screen that is actually the width of paper. a TV set that is as thin as paper and doesn't waste so much energy as LCD screens. A Cellphone that has a sliding screen that is COMPLETELY retractable. A monitor to show you the news headlines, that is wireless and recieves data from your wireless computer/network that you can put ON your fridge. A think sheet of material they can put in the cockpit of F-18 instead of the EXTREMELY expensive and EXTERMELY problematic lcd headup displays they use nowadays. This is NOT JUST FROM REPLACING BOOKS. It will revolutionize the way we display information. All thats missing is MASS production and color. The oportunities are endless. |
|||
|
|||
Looking at the animation (not the text) it seems that ePaper has found a way to make like charges attract and unlike charges repel. This is a huge deal people. This flips the known laws of electromagnetism and is worth a Nobel Prize if it is true. |
|||
|
|||
that`s nice | |||
|
|||
new thing same stuff | |||
|
|||
Dear Sir/Madam, Perhaps this message comes to the wrong person, in that case please forward it to the person in your company who is responsible for purchasing of printed circuit boards. Startrack Circuits Ltd is one professional PCB manufacturer, till now, we have already passed ISO9001,2000 certification and other relative certification. Our quality control system was accept by more and more customer. We mainly supply single side, double side and multilayer rigid printed circuit board. Normally, we can finish the PCBs within 7 working days for a 6 layers board or below.Within Eight working days for boards with layers above 6. For 2 layer pcb with normal size, we can achieve the competitive price to USD 0.074 per cm2. for mass production boards, we can provide free protyping. If any other infomation you needed, please feel free to contact me or take an audit in our plant. We welcome customers around the world to audit in plant. |
|||
|
|||
Dear Sir/Madam, Perhaps this message comes to the wrong person, in that case please forward it to the person in your company who is responsible for purchasing of printed circuit boards. Startrack Circuits Ltd is one professional PCB manufacturer, till now, we have already passed ISO9001,2000 certification and other relative certification. Our quality control system was accept by more and more customer. We mainly supply single side, double side and multilayer rigid printed circuit board. Normally, we can finish the PCBs within 7 working days for a 6 layers board or below.Within Eight working days for boards with layers above 6. For 2 layer pcb with normal size, we can achieve the competitive price to USD 0.074 per cm2. for mass production boards, we can provide free protyping. If any other infomation you needed, please feel free to contact me or take an audit in our plant. We welcome customers around the world to audit in plant. |
|||
|
|||
Badly need your help. Your world is made of your memories, and your memories are given to you by your world. The whispering voice of happenstance is always in our ears. 'This is the world. This is the way things are. Look. Pay attention. Remember.' I am from Fiji and now teach English, tell me right I wrote the following sentence: "Chinese gay lesbian movies chinese movie database gay lesbian." With love :P, Hibah. |
|||
|
|||
This looks amazing! If this does work, then that means less trees will be needed to cut down to make old-fashioned paper, meaning we'll be helping out the world in a whole new way! OMFG!!! |
|||
|
|||
It is realy amazing to think in the future. How great if this invention is a possibility not just to minimize the cutting of forests, the wastage of energy and the invaluable element water, which is needed so much to produce paper. i am all on edge - the next years are thrilling forsure. I am looking forward to an e paper siding for the shower - changing color, music. More relevant: immense content with an affordable medium. Great! Lisa from Leipzig |
|||
|
|||
Makhubele, please have look at this article | |||
|
|||
iybgnlvcxfvgybhunijkmol,cdfgvybhunjmkl,hgbv;yhhnijm'olk[porjkewqr]4o5j tkyre[gkptopkh\[trkotrihypotttropgk;tfokh;'dfkhgpsdkf[pfkoerpkgwp;ykjo lkykouriotypjr6iioryerwpthiojuorijhijyuhiotyjuuohiojuyjhtolpglplp[loki jgt7gyufedswy56ueruhrfuhhnfj |
|||
|
|||
ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiissssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss sssssssssshhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhffffffffff ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiissssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss ssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss ssssssssssssssshhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh |
|||
|
|||
Why not create a desktop in white screen. You can make a desktop tall as a wall. No cinema only epaper. Or a simple userdesktop, the eyes would be happy. Lots of people read the hole day the sceen. |
|||
|
|||
Please note | |||
|
|||
hey, think E-wallpaper | |||
|
|||
CAN U GAVE ME PAPERS |
|||
|
|||
Some specialists state that loan help a lot of people to live the way they want, just because they are able to feel free to buy necessary goods. Moreover, a lot of banks offer credit loan for all people. |
|||
|
|||
Keep the e paper simple in design, why because , thats all paper is, simple https://spapaperlessproject.wordpress.com |
|||
|
|||
i love this. now i want the bracelet | |||
|
|||
What will e-paper cost in the near future?Say maybe 2012. | |||
|
|||
make the e paper exactly like a newspaper, the only difference being you plug the paper into the internet and download the days news.You can then use the epaper over and over again without having to buy a new one, and thus stopping the need to cut down trees ,waste lots of money on printing and paper disposal into landfill. It could be brilliant!! |
|||
|
|||
Hi guys! I once saw a plastic sheet with milky color. When covered against a dark background plate, one can write on it with a ink-less "pen". But when taken off the background plate, the handwriting disappears. Do you know what it is and where I can buy it? |